Here's the summary of a study I just completed about opening gaps on the S&P (SPY). The study is designed to test the propensity of gaps to fill on the day of the gap, based on 1) the "zone" in which the gap opens and 2) the direction of the market the day before the gap.
The zones are lettered from A to F on the left and each represents the following:
Zone A - Opens above the high of the prior day.
Zone B - Opens between the high and the top of the real body (i.e. inside upper wick).
Zone C - Open inside the top half of the real body.
Zone D - Open inside the bottom half of the real body.
Zone E - Open inside the lower wick.
Zone F - Opens below the low the prior day.
The other variable is the prior day's trading direction. As the numbers show, this is an important consideration when playing gaps.
I have listed the Sharpe ratio, the Profit factor and the Win % for 3 different trade strategies:
1. Long at the open, exit at close.
2. Short at the open, exit at close.
3. Fade the gap, exit at gap fill.
I'll let the numbers speak for themselves, but you should note that some strategies play out very differently in their propensity to fill versus their propensity to close in that direction.
For instance B area gaps following an up day (continuation gaps) are clearly the best trades (short). They tend to fill at whopping 90.3% of the time and close lower 57% of the time. Even better, gaps that open in this zone can also be profitably held (short) for bigger targets.
Quite another story however, D area gaps following a down day tend to fill 84.4% of the time (short), but holding the same trade through the close is barely a breakeven strategy. Holding too long here would be deadly as you will tend to give back most of your profits.
Finally, these results represent perfect trades with NO STOPS. You should use this info only to understand the basic tendency and likely direction of a gap day, not as a complete trading system.
